How Big Chad Law Signed 50+ PI Cases and Opened a 6th Office in 4 Months
An Arizona personal injury firm was drowning in unqualified leads. We fixed their tracking, rebuilt their strategy, and fueled an office expansion.
High Lead Volume, Low Case Quality
In Q1 2025, Big Chad Law noticed a concerning downward trend in actual case acquisitions despite high lead volume. While their staff remained busy on the phones, a growing percentage of leads were failing to convert into signed cases, often being marked as spam. They needed to shift away from 'raw leads' and find a way to target high-quality, qualified personal injury cases.
Multi-Channel Surround Sound
Creekside deployed a sophisticated multi-channel approach to capture and qualify demand. Meta Ads drove high-level brand awareness across Arizona. Google Search Ads captured high-intent users and the demand generated by Meta. Local Service Ads provided guaranteed lead quality and maximized top-of-page real estate.
The critical innovation was advanced tracking: we refined tracking to identify which leads actually became qualified cases, specifically optimizing for phone calls lasting over 3 minutes. By feeding higher-quality data signals back into Google's bidding algorithms, lead-to-case conversion stabilized dramatically.
Consistent Case Flow and Physical Expansion
Between April and September 2025, Big Chad Law saw a massive stabilization in lead-to-case conversion.
Monthly Case Acquisition
| Month | Signed Cases | Ad Spend | CPA (Per Case) |
|---|---|---|---|
| April 2025 | 15 | $12,881 | $858.77 |
| May 2025 | 18 | $18,622 | $1,034.58 |
| June 2025 | 17 | $14,031 | $825.35 |
| July 2025 | 19 | $22,220 | $1,169.48 |
| August 2025 | 21 | $21,774 | $1,036.88 |
| September 2025 | 12 | $7,455 | $621.28 |
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the lowest cost per signed personal injury case this campaign achieved?
The lowest monthly cost per signed PI case was $621.28, achieved in September 2025. That figure represents cost per signed retainer, not cost per lead -- every inquiry still had to be qualified by intake staff and converted into an actual signed case. Across the full six-month reporting window from April through September 2025, Big Chad Law signed more than 50 PI cases from this campaign structure.
How did tracking phone call duration improve lead quality for this law firm?
We refined conversion tracking to count only phone calls lasting over 3 minutes as qualified conversion events. A call under 3 minutes is almost never a serious personal injury inquiry -- it is a wrong number, a competitor check, or a caller who disqualifies quickly. Feeding 3-plus-minute calls back into Google's bidding algorithm as the conversion signal shifted the campaign away from optimizing for raw call volume and toward optimizing for genuine case prospects. That change was the primary driver behind the stabilization in lead-to-case conversion rate.
Why did Big Chad Law open a sixth office, and how did paid advertising contribute?
The sixth office opened because the campaign generated consistent, qualified case volume over a four-month period that justified the additional overhead. From April through September 2025, Big Chad Law signed more than 50 PI cases across their Arizona locations. At average PI case fees, that volume generates substantial revenue. The predictability of the paid acquisition funnel -- knowing approximately how many signed cases would come from a given monthly spend -- gave the firm the data to make a growth decision with confidence.
What is the difference between Local Service Ads and Google Search Ads for personal injury law firms?
Local Service Ads (LSAs) show at the very top of Google above traditional paid search ads and are pay-per-lead rather than pay-per-click. For personal injury, LSAs provide Google-screened placement and guaranteed lead quality. Google Search Ads sit below LSAs and operate on a cost-per-click model with more control over keywords and messaging. This campaign ran both simultaneously as part of a surround sound strategy -- LSAs captured the top-of-page real estate while Google Search Ads captured high-intent keyword searches. Meta Ads added brand awareness across Arizona that fed demand into both Google channels.
Qualified PI Cases Signed
As a direct result of this campaign's profitability, Big Chad Law was able to expand its physical footprint and open a sixth office in Arizona. The combination of brand awareness, intent capture, and quality-optimized tracking created a repeatable system for case acquisition.
More Results Like This
Winterbotham Parham TeepleBankruptcy Law Firm Doubles Conversions and Cuts CPA 42% with Google Ads
How we restructured Google Ads for a bankruptcy law firm, doubling conversions from 117 to 229 while reducing cost per conversion by 42% to $50.29.
LawnValueLawnValue Generates 2,000+ Leads and Expands to Florida with Digital Marketing
How a Tennessee lawn care company replaced traditional mailers with a full-funnel digital strategy, generating 2,000+ leads, ranking #13 on Google Maps, and funding a new Florida branch in under 12 months.
Adventures in WisdomEducation Brand Cuts CPA 52% While Doubling Application Volume
How we took over Meta Ads management and cut cost-per-application from $256 to $123 while more than doubling monthly applications from 41 to 90.